In Nicholas Carr’s
essay “Is Google Making us Stupid” he states that he feels like the internet is
changing the way people’s minds work and think.
He says that deep reading used to come naturally and that his mind would
get caught up in the narrative. But he has
noticed that as he has spent a lot more time online, he’s not thinking the way
he used think. He loses his concentration,
gets fidgety, and gets distracted more easily when reading. He feels like media is reprogramming us. Carr Supports his ideas by stating that he’s
not the only one who feels this way.
Carr interviewed psychologist Maryanne Wolf, who said that the efficiency
and immediacy style of reading promoted by the Net may be weakening our ability
to read deeply. Carr also mentions
Friedrich Nietzsche whose writing style changed because he went from writing in
pen to writing on a typewriter. The
invention of the clock has even changed the way we act and think. Carr talks about studies that have been done
on the human brain and how even the adult mind is constantly reprogramming
itself and altering the way it functions and how media has affected it. Then Carr discusses the thoughts of the two
young men who founded Google. Apparently
they desire to turn Google into an artificial intelligence machine that might
be connected to our brains somehow. They
think if we had a smarter artificial brain attached to our own brain that we’d
be better off. This is scary because
they make it seem like the brain is outdated and not enough. In the end, Carr wraps up by stating his
fears of us turning into “pancake people” spread wide and thin as we connect
with all this information accessed by the touch of a button. We have come to rely on computers and it is
like our own human intelligence is flattening into artificial intelligence.
I think Carr’s essay really relates to the topic of my
blog. Technology, the internet, and
social media all have benefits and have helped improve society in certain
ways. But Carr really points out how the
internet is actually changing the way our mind thinks and works. Just like in my post about social media
addiction, social media has the ability to change your brain chemistry and the
way we act. Carr made a lot of good points in his essay and it made me think from
a different perspective. It even made me
realize how it’s affecting me. I thought
about it and realized that I also rarely read books anymore and that it’s
really hard to focus if the reading is long and I’m not particularly interested
in it. But do I think that Google is making us stupid? No. But I do agree with
some things Carr pointed out. The internet
and social media can negatively affect us greatly. But I also think it’s a great tool and can
really help us. I believe it’s all about
how you use it.
I agree about a lot of what you are saying, however wouldn't we all be better off if we could analyze, process, and assimilate information quicker. Neural computing would enable us to outpace our current technological climb... Perhaps the current pace does need a more settled and easy transition, although I am loath to admit such.
ReplyDelete